Pepper Jelly & Cream Cheese Dip: An Easy 2-Ingredient Appetizer

You know the kind of recipe that isn’t really a recipe at all – it’s just a list of ingredients for assembly? This is one of those recipes.

I first learned about this non-recipe when my sister-in-law brought it to a holiday gathering 5-10 years ago, and I was dumbfounded by how simple yet tasty it was. It was the perfect balance of creamy, sweet, and a little spicy (though honestly, it’s not even really spicy), and it only takes two ingredients – three if you count the crackers you need to eat it with.

Cream cheese and a jar of pepper jelly.

ingredients for pepper jelly

Pepper jelly is made of a combination of sweet bell peppers and chili peppers (like jalapeños). It’s not uncommon to also see raspberry pepper jelly, which includes raspberries in addition to the combination of peppers.

It’s usually not as spicy as you might think. Even the Trader Joe’s brand you see here, labeled “Hot & Sweet,” isn’t really that hot; the sweetness from the jelly really offsets any heat. A lot of my family members don’t do spicy food, but they still love this dip!

How to Make Pepper Jelly & Cream Cheese Dip

  1. Set out the cream cheese: Place a block of cream cheese on a small to medium dish and let it come to room temperature (at least 30 minutes). Tip: Make sure you use a plate with a slight inward slope, as the jelly will run to the edges.
  2. Top with jelly: Pour an entire jar of pepper jelly right on top. Some brands are runnier than others (the Trader Joe’s one I used here is definitely on the runnier side). While some recipes online call for just 1/2 cup or so of jelly, in my opinion, that’s not nearly enough! Some brands are 8 oz, and some are 11-12 oz. I usually just dump it all on. LOL
  3. Serve and enjoy: Using a butter knife, spread a dab onto your cracker. For this “recipe,” I prefer sturdy, non-crumbly crackers like Wheat Thins. They are perfect for a one-bite drop into the mouth.
a cracker with a scoop of the dip

Alternative presentation: I’ll admit, it looks pretty at first (even if my dark plate didn’t photograph well – sorry!), but once everyone starts digging in, it can get a little messy. If you prefer a cleaner presentation, try whipping the cream cheese and jelly together with a hand mixer instead. Just make sure the cream cheese is fully at room temperature so you don’t end up with unblended bits of cream cheese.

Also, keep in mind that this whipped method works best with a thicker jelly. In the photo below, I actually used my own homemade jar of pepper jelly – not the Trader Joe’s one – because it had a lot thicker consistency. The Trader Joe’s version is actually quite runny (but still tasty!)

If your jelly is runny and you whip it with the cream cheese, it will just end up a runny dip, and you don’t want that. If all you have is runny jam and you want to do the whipped version, start by adding just half a jar of jelly. I also refrigerate it for 1-2 hours after whipping so it sets a bit.

whipped together

Baked Versions

If you Google “Red Peppery Cream Cheese Dip,” you’ll find variations online that are hot-dip versions where you add shredded cheese, mayo, and seasonings to the cream cheese, spread it in a baking dish, top with the jelly, and then bake. I’m sure they’re delicious, too!

That being said, I have never even tried the hot variation because I love the simplicity of having some “recipes” in my mix that are easy, because sometimes we need that. I’ve chosen to delight in the simple version of this appetizer, and I hope you enjoy it as well!

Where to Get Pepper Jelly

Full disclosure: Pepper jelly can be a little tricky to track down. Neither of my small-town grocers (Walmart or Kroger) carries it. If you live in a larger city with bigger grocery stores, you’ll likely have better luck. As you saw in this post, Trader Joe’s also carries their own version, or you can easily order a jar on Amazon.

My personal favorite is Bonnie’s Jams Pepper Jelly. It’s a LOT pricier than the Trader Joe’s version, so I consider it a special treat, but its thicker consistency and vibrant color make for a nice presentation. Plus, I find that the 8oz. jar gives you the ideal ratio of jelly to cream cheese.

trader joes pepper jelly $2.99

Pepper Jelly & Cream Cheese Dip

The ultimate effortless appetizer! Two ingredients and a box of crackers make for the perfect sweet, creamy, and savory crowd-pleaser.
Prep Time 2 minutes
Total Time 2 minutes
Servings: 8
Course: Appetizer
Cuisine: American

Ingredients
  

  • 1 block cream cheese
  • 1 jar pepper jelly
  • 1 box Wheat Thins or other cracker of choice

Method
 

  1. Set cream cheese in a small to medium dish and let it come to room temperature.
  2. Pour pepper jelly on top.
  3. Use a butter knife to spread onto crackers and enjoy!

You Might Also Like

 
AFFILIATE DISCLOSURE
Please note that Piano Pantry is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Simply put, being an associate allows me to make a small percentage from Amazon on items to which I link at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating